A response to Obang Metho’s false allegations over Gambella incident!
By Pagak Nyier
Ethiopian News, Tigrai Online, February 28, 2016
What kind of Gambelia do we really want? I am sure we all want Gambella free from the conflict and violence. There have been allegations which have been aired by Ginvot-7 supporters with no realistic evidence. I will elaborate a bit on what really happened in Gambella State.
Unfortunately, we can describe that our Region has been victimized since 1991 by the nature of unpleasant acts in a way that makes us all feel angry and violated. The same tragedy happened again in Gambella in 2003 due to an unpleasant plan by a certain Anyuak group, where they ambushed high profile veteran Highlanders. This is our home (Gambella) as well and we all should intend to help make its better place for all Ethiopians and foreigners.
Obang Metho’s allegations were reported on Eritrean Satellite Television as well as allegations by Nyikwa Ochalla, Ojulu Obang, and other anti-government elements. These allegations are not true.
On February 3 2016, Obang Metho twisted his urgent article about the incident that had happened between Nuer and Anyawa’s in Gambella. Therefore, his article is filled with distortion and fabrications. Also, the article he wrote betrays what really happened in Gambella between Anyuak and the Nuer communities. In the following weeks, I put forth brief background information and facts about what is really happening in the State of Gambella, facts in which Obang Metho chooses to be oblivious about in hopes to gain momentum. Negative if not a naïve! To correct his miss-facts and his negative analysis report, I will simply select and reckon parts from his allegation article that are unfound pieces of evidence. If you have gotten jealous because of the way Gambella has risen for development in less than two years, then you are wrong.
The root causes of the recent conflict in Gambella Regional State and Anyuak and Nuer life is matter:
The first incident that was reported came from the Nuer people of Puldeng and the Anyuak people of Paanywaa village, where a Nuer man accidentally killed a pregnant Anywaa woman months back. After the incident happened and was brought up again, Gambella Regional State authority took quick action to manage the incident. The State laws and local community followed and gave compensation to the husband of the deceased Anywaa woman. A few days later, the husband decided to take revenge by taking the lives of two Nuers. Therefore, anger started circulating between the two communities, Nuer of Puldeng and Paanywaa Anyuak village alone.
A few months later, another incident happened between the vice president driver Engineer Ato Oleru and Gambella’s elected official who was hired by the regional government at the Teachers Training Institute (TTI) College. Apparently, a dispute had happened between these two gentlemen and could not be resolved in a peaceful manner, possibly due to some hidden agendas between the Region and outsiders.
Eventually, Ato Obang Metho stated the incident in a wrong way by saying that “the Anyuak man who was the Deputy President’s driver, had legally leased the land a few months ago, with plans to eventually build a home on it. The border of the land had been demarcated and he held a clear title to it, given to him by the government authorities. Recently, the Nuer man from Gambella University, decided he wanted that same land. The Anyuak man told him you cannot take the land because he had the legal rights to it.” Then, a physical fight broke out between two men, the vice president driver and the Dean College ministry. The Nuer punched his rival in the face, soon later he fired gun shots into the air in hopes to avoid being harmed by his opponent. Hereafter, his opponent then shoots at him and a gain the Nuer man turned his gun at the Anyuak man and shot him in his hand. This could be a normal incident if not because there are hidden agendas behind it.
One week later, another physical fight broke out between college students, this was not the only caused the incident that killed innocent people of Gambella. There are several sources which need to be revealed and dug out by the government. There is no land grabbing by the same people who own the same land. Enthusiastically, the writer had got wrong report that he really want to make another search or clarification of what is really happened in the State of Gambella if not because he spoke Rebel (Ginvot-7) language. Let me make it clear for you one more time. The land lease was legally leased for both citizens and the incident would blamed on the authority who leased the land for both citizens. This is where the incident came from. Due to miscommunication and lack of communication on both sides, who do we are really blame here. We hope investigators will figure it out.
Certainly, advance evil acts continue to destroy lives in Gambella. Another attack on Nuer students at the college campus happened the week after the shooting happened over a land dispute. At the college, two Nuer female students were beaten to death by Anyuak. After the death of the young women was announced, one Anyuak took another attack on students where he threw a hand grenade into a crowd of students, the grenade failed to discharge and reached its target, where he thought he could have killed most Nuer students. Luckily, no student was injured nor killed. But, the attacker received a minor injury and was taken to a hospital in Gambella. Thereafter, the Nuer community convinced themselves not to do the same evil acts that the Anyuaks were (and still doing) and agreed that only justice will punish those who are committing crimes against the Nuer. Unfortunately, Anyuaks failed to convince themselves to apologize to the family of the deceased.
Where did the attacker get a hand grenade from? Who is behind this evil plan to kill as many Nuer students as possible with a hand grenade? Could this be related to the terror acts that happened in other Regions which were coordinated by Ginvot-7?
Thus, the allegations that were spread out about a Nuer student that threw a hand grenade at college students are false. On the same day and the same hour later, several killings were carried out by Anyuak Special Forces, killing Nuer who live in all Anyuak Waredas. These Anyuak Special forces who are supposed to protect the region instead of turning themselves into a tribal forces also killed an unarmed Nuer in or around Abobo Wareda town; the deceased was a deputy minister of road and transportation in the region.
Several Nuer Special Force who were officially stationed in Anyuak Woredas to protect citizens were also discriminately shot and killed in Jor Wareda. Another killing was conducted in Abobo prison where 14 Nuer refugee inmates were all killed in Abobo Wareda. This could be a violation of both national and international human rights laws.
In fact, the Gambella jail was stormed by prisoners who tried to sneak out from jail, no guns were used to shot at one another. Both sides used only stones and sticks to fight, resulting in deaths on both sides. It is unlawful for prisoners to be killed, if act continues in the region, Gambella could be polluted with ethnicity hatred. Lack of good evidence can sometimes turn a writer/reporter to be a very cheap man. And this is exactly what Obang Metho’s article fits. Obang claims in his article that Ethiopian Nuer citizens have risen the South Sudanese flag to replace the Ethiopian flag outside of Gambella’s big prison and Newland. The Nuer people of Ethiopia are not dumb enough to do such a thing in the country because they are Ethiopians like any other Ethiopians and they love Ethiopia. Obang Metho apparently shows he is playing the ethnicity card by not telling the facts and his article is too bias and should not be trusted at all. His article amounts to WHITE LIES EVEN A 5-YEAR-OLD CHILD COULD NOT BELIEVE!
Save lives of many:
In the meantime, the Nuer elders together with administrative spared unarmed Anyuaks from all Nuer Waredas and brought them to Lare, more than 350 Anyuaks all were save. In less than an hour, Gambella’s President Ato Gatluak gave the order to transport all of them from Lare Wareda to Gambella without any missing person. Why was this not done in Abobo, Pugnido and Jor? Repeated, no doubt in many minds that there could be a hidden agenda behind Anyuak rebellious acts of killing any Nuer they find which caused that incident to explode beyond the point that many people could not imagine. January 2016 killing in Gambella and other areas could be compared to what had happened back in 2003 when an Anyuak group ambushed high profile ARRA officials and TPLF veterans on their way back from Lare to Gambella. More lives from Anyawaa had been lost even though some were spared by Nuer. Why do Anyuak simply forget the good things that the Nuer have done for them? It is first time in my life to see Anyuak acting ungrateful towards Nuer who had save their love ones in 2003.
Past and current administrative subdivisions:
- Agwa Alemu (GPLM) 1991 – 1992: were killed by his own community
- Okello Ouman (GPLM) 1992 – 1997: had played ethnicity and hatred rules
- Okello Gnigelo (GPDF) August 1997 – 2003: had played ethnicity and hatred rules
- Okello Akway 2003 – 2004: had played ethnicity hatred rules
- Keat Tuach Bithow (acting) January 2004 – 2005: had less time to fulfill his job
- Dr. Omod Obong (GPDM) 29 September 2005–2013: had united Nuer and Anyuak but too much corruptions
- Gatluak Tut Khot (GPDM) 2013-present: he brings real development to the Region and united all fives indigenous!
Where these parties are existing? Are these two parties responsible to last month incident, Gambella Nilotes United movement (GNUM) and Gambella Nilotes Movement Army (GNUM/A) operates? I know there is only party in the Region, Gambella Peoples' Democratic Movement (GPDM) or የጋምቤላ ሕዝቦች ዴሞክራሲያዊ ንቅናቄ is existing in Gambella.
GAMBELLA.IS THE RICH AND MOST BEAUTIFUL LAND, WHY IS IT BECOMING A BACKWARD STATE THAN OTHER ETHIOPIAN STATES?
Why is Gambella which is rich and beautiful become the most backward, poorest, less developed, and full of ethnicity hatred? Could this incident be a divine curse in the region of Gambella or could it be a curse which the people of Gambella do not consider themselves as one and people who do not believe in detestation? Is there any secret within these two ethnic groups which has not been exposed to the later generations?
Hence, there is no certain group within the region who is documented to have been the first to originate in Gambella. The ongoing incident has portrayed some reasons on why Gambella is a backward state and immature for many years. Brothers and sisters, let our reasons for peace flow in—we need to see how we can move our region and people out of backwardness thinking, underdevelopment and hatred.
We are the citizens of this Gambella Region. We are irritated, sickened and tormented by the barbaric killings of innocent Nuer and Anyuak’s. We are torn by this great tragedy and we must join to be peaceful makers to express our outrage and condemnation of this aggressive act driven by enmity against innocent people of Gambella. It would be our spirit in our minds that we would call upon our elders and youths to stop the killing and bring those criminals to justice as soon as possible--so that responsible individuals who committed crimes from both parties would face the consequences in the eye of Ethiopian Laws.
Literally, each single life is considered sacred in both communities and this has been explicitly stated in our tradition. We do not believe in killing and we care for justice for every single individual. There is no place for rebellion of any form in our Gambella Region. As one family, we want to show other Regions that we have nothing to do with such activities of violence and we must denounce those who have to kill who in Gambella! At the same time, it is very sad for both communities to see some group is being associated with such criminal activities—Ginvot--7 group.
I do really believe that serving refugee in Ethiopia Regions particularly the Gambella Region, Tigray Region and Somalia Region shall not be a Regional problem or choice. It is a country and International Community agreement to serves displace people in any locations. Nuer and Anyuak both migrated from Sudan particular South Sudan to Ethiopia without doubt.
Obang Metho must understand that Gambellian people are not dumb enough to accept rebel acts in the Region with existential threat by demanding the killing of Nuer because they think they will have a chance to enter Gambella. The tragic irony is that in the current dispute between the Nuer and Anyuak over the land, that was made available for both communities, there is absolutely not truth. I entreaty all you young students to educate yourselves on both sides, Nuer and Anyuak. How are we going to change our region Gambella? Have you seen the harmful effects of last Month’s violent extremes that happened in our region? I appeal to you all young Gambellians! How can young people in Gambella come together to advocate a message of peace and to terrace from ethnicity hatred?
There is no evidence to support that the two ethnic groups will not ever collaborate again. I am not sure that those who are incapable to preach peace to restores back to Gambella shall think. It is very unfortunate when someone is compelled to descend to the lowest level, discouraging simply because the other community fails to appreciate them for what they have done for the other, they sometimes take it as sign of weakness or acceptance of fears. Eritrean Satellite Television (ESAT) channel and Ginvot--7 reports do not deserve to destroy Gambella Region by listening negative reports. This killing was not happened only on Nuer alone. It had happened many years go and this an example, “These psycho-cultural differences accompanied with frustration aggression theories reached to the point of no-return unless managed wisely. Ironically, the conflict between local Nuers and Anyuaks meant a conflict between refugees too” ( Zeray Hailemariam).
I would urge the readers to go through the whole piece and judge for herself/himself. Finally, I would conclude by stated to you that above writer had trade of unfound evidences, Gambella shall prevail and thrive. Ginvot 7 ill report would never be true. I believe the above writer must try to reason with Gambella residents to come up with true reports and preach resolution to the problems. I also believe the writer and Ginvot---7 supporters’ who reside outside of the country, their contentions efforts toward the Region will fail totally!
When I toured all Waredas and met with residents from Lare, Nuer Zone Nyinanyang, Especial Wareda Itang, Abol Wareda, Abobo, Pugnido Wareda and Jor Wareda. I did not hear any words about conflicts between these two groups, Anyuak and Nuer. What I did hear from the places mentioned above when I was touring was only Murle issue, kidnapping children and some un-development in certain areas. In the few weeks after I came back to the States, finally very disturbing news occurred that our people are killing each other.
I express my condolences to the families and friends of the victims and express my outrage at such an abhorrent ferocity that was committed to both of our communities. I have no words to express the horror and sadness I felt about these criminal acts.
The author lives in Gambella, Ethiopia. He can be reached @firstname.lastname@example.org