General Tsadkan’s description may be plausible, but his prescription is beyond the bounds of possibility
logo Tigrai Online - Ethiopian Daily News

General Tsadkan’s description may be plausible, but his prescription is beyond the bounds of possibility

By Dilwenberu Nega
Tigrai Online, Ethiopian News, July 26, 2016

General Tsadkan’s description may be plausible, but his prescription is beyond the bounds of possibility

Sponsored Links

Friendly but firm, a celebrated strategist, a tried and tested fighter of the liberation struggle and FDRE’s first Chief of Staff of the Defence Forces, Retd. Lt. General Tsadkan Gebre Tinsay, is known by his peers for “speaking up before he blows up.” He was depoliticized, in accordance with the Constitution in 1994 when he became a Chief of Staff, and demilitarised himself following the fall-out of the TPLF split in 2000. He is therefore entitled to opine on political matters despite the military handle to his name. Besides Prime Minister Haile Mariam Desalgn’s “participatory and listening administration” encourages the general public to make use of the freedom of speech enshrined in the Constitution. At a consultative meeting held some weeks ago with the literati from colleges and universities, Prime Minister Haile Mariam spoke so vividly about the need for the public to speak up whenever they come across instances of jobbery, maladministration, abuse of power and rent seeking.

Gen. Tsadkan’s recent 13 page in Tigrai Online written in Amharic Former Chief of Staff of the Ethiopian Defense Forces, Lt. General Tsadkan Gebretensae, speaks about the current political situation in Ethiopia  ”  also in Amharic on and in Tigrigna in aigaforum went viral on the internet and managed to spur a sense of utter disbelief from those who believe that the reality on the ground in Ethiopia  is not as dark and as foreboding as General Tsadkan portrays it to be, while his analysis had allowed exponents of “just-in-time politics” (a form of politics in which ad hoc coalitions and relationships are built around issues instead of ideologies) to have an unwarranted field day.

This script tries to zoom on General Tsadkan’s declared remedies with the view not to debunk them per se, but to point out that his prescriptions, far from addressing the political crises would make them even more complex and unmanageable. Prescriptions must be in line with the diagnosis. As no good comes out from prescribing chemo-therapy to someone who suffers migraine, so too no good will come out from prescribing a remedy for assumed or actual political crises that the GoE is seen to be facing. While I make no effort to portray myself as a revolutionary with a proven democratic dispensation as General Tsakani, sheer common sense spurs me to conclude that his analysis has, intentionally or unintentionally, over-egged the political crises which, it must be noted, are being addressed by EPRDF’s ongoing rectification program. Judging by the concentrated and implacable resolve the general public has given to the Government’s no-nonsense approach to corruption, to misuse of office, abuse of power and rent seeking – the root causes of the political crises – there is rising sense of confidence – and certainly not lack of confidence – that EPRDF has now got things under control. It must of course be remembered EPRDF’s remedies are not effervescent pills which work instantly they are taken. The level of mandate the electorate gave EPRDF demands that the Government be given time to prove its people-based remedies bear fruit.

In his preamble, General Tsadkan makes no secret of his desire to lay emphatic stress on the need for nothing less than a paradigm shift to be on top of “Ethiopia’s political crises” all to be implemented “in line with the Constitution of FDRE” because he believes that the unfolding political crises demands that they be addressed not only by the party and state, but the opposition-at-large. His prescription, now dubbed “The Tsadkan formula” calls for:

  1. The full implementation of the provisions of the Constitution.
  2. The unfettered activities
  3. The willingness by the EPRDF to accept the outcome of a general election observed by international observers.

This formula has all the hallmarks of an oxymoronic proposal. On the one had it pledges assurance, persuasion, fidelity and loyalty to the Constituition; while on the other hand it introduces ideas knowing full well that they clash head-on with FDRE’s written constitution. Ethiopia is a pluralistic democracy where Parliament is sovereign.

In the May 2015 Election the electorate, secure in the knowledge that a divided opposition does not have what it takes to lead Ethiopia and mindful of the fact EPRDF delivers on manifesto promises, had returned EPRDF to office with a thumping majority. The fact that no opposition had managed to secure a seat in the HPR, may provide fodder to those hell-bent at demeaning Ethiopia’s own stride to democratisation, but it does not alter the irrefutable reality on the ground. For far too long, EPRDF has been at the receiving end of blame and criticism for the weaknesses and in-fighting prevalent inside Ethiopia’s gallimaufry opposition, as if EPRDF is meant to be their nanny. The naked truth, there for everyone to witness, is that the great majority of the 60 odd opposition parties in Ethiopia are still in their swaddling clothes and therefore are no match for agrarian EPRDF in terms of resource, organisational discipline and committed members.

What kind of remedy can come out by turning our backs on the millions who voted for EPRDF at the last election?

In layman’s term what the General is calling for is nothing less than a snap general election, because in his learned wisdom the people of Ethiopia have lost confidence in EPRDF. Only time can tell whose prescription works best for Ethiopia. It is my humble opinion that our celebrated General has failed to err on the side of caution.

More Articles

Sponsored Links

Ethiopia suspends importing medicine from 11 Egyptian pharmaceutical companies

Eritrean soldiers and 400 hundred Afar rebels abandoned PFDJ

Is war with Eritrea justified?

Ethiopia, Djibouti, and China to launch $4 Billion natural gas project

Has push not come to shove yet for the Government

A stern reminder to the Ethiopian Federal government

Israeli PM visit to Ethiopia is scaring Eritrea and terrifying Egypt

Ethiopia and Israel sign various agreements to strengthen their ties

Ethiopia and Israel sign various agreements to strengthen their ties

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu arrives in Ethiopia

The right decision at the right time for the right country- Ethiopia

We need to send Eritrea to the International Criminal Court

Ethiopia becomes a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council

Ethiopia blends hospitality, heritages and developmental agenda

Eritrean tyrant and his henchmen to be tried for crimes against humanity

Supporters of Isaias Afwerki are delusional beyond cure

The magnitude of damage to Eritrean Forces in Tserona and Badme fronts in Eritrea

Eritrea says Ethiopia is planning full scale war against the tiny nation

Eritrean leaders claim the United States of America has deployed weapons in the border

Go Ethiopia Go: Ethiopia’s Smart War of Attrition

The gallant Ethiopian Defense Forces have delivered a very clear message to the arrogant Eritrean leadersa

Heavy fighting erupted between Eritrea and Ethiopia

The gallant Ethiopian defense forces destroyed 245 Al-Shabaab fighters in Somalia

UN recommends Eritrean leaders should be tried for crimes against humanity

The Centerpiece of all Rights and Opportunities is the Participation and Benefits of the Public

World Bank approves 300 million dollars for urban transport in Ethiopia

Ethiopia seeks to be Africa's top car manufacturer With Chinese help

Reflections on Strategy for Sweden’s Development Cooperation with Ethiopia

Egyptian minister calls black Africans dogs and slaves

Eritrean mercenaries tell their own story

South Korean President Park Geun-hye visiting Ethiopia

Ethiopia to build another mega hydroelectric plant, Koysha Hydroelectric Dam

A riposte to Major Dawit’s odious remarks on Tigraians and Woyane

Eritrea: Silver Jubilee celebration or commiseration?

Eritrean terrorist group armed to the teeth managed to enter southern Ethiopia

Engaging Ethiopian Amhara Diaspora

This is the Brotherhood plan for America, what is the plan for Ethiopia?

Ethiopia quietly building its air defense systems

The hidden agenda beyond religion in Ethiopia

A false narrative to make Ethiopians trust Isaias Afewerki

Challenges and Prospects of Good Governance in Tigrai-Ethiopia

Opinions published on this site are those of the authors and not necessarily those of Tigrai Online.
©2005-2016 All rights reserved.