logo Tigrai Online

Ethnic federalism is not the reason Ethiopia is disintegrating

Tigrai Online Editorial, July 25, 2019

Ethnic federalism is not the reason Ethiopia is disintegratingEthnic federalism is not the reason Ethiopia is fragmenting, but the greed of elite Amharas and the incompetent prime minister.

Ethiopia is in the process of fragmenting like the former Yugoslavia did in the nineteen nineties. The reason why Ethiopia is tearing itself apart at the seams is not because the way it is structured currently.

The causes for the ongoing fragmentation of Ethiopia are not ethnic federalism or the Ethiopian constitution giving the Ethiopian people self determination up to secession.

The Ethiopian government is structured in nine regional states based on ethnic, linguistic, geographic amalgamation. The implementation of the federal structure gave the people of Ethiopia the power to be an active participant in decision making, safe guarding their interests, the right to own land and other resources, plan and map out their own political affairs within the Ethiopian federal system.

The federal restructuring also distributed political and economic power that was concentrated in one place, namely Addis Ababa and one ethnic group for almost a century to all the regional states.

Some analysts blame the Ethiopian federal system and constitution for the political unrest in Ethiopia in the past four or five years and now. Exclusively Ethiopian Amhara elites and activists are completely certain the Ethiopian federal system is harmful to their interests. The main reason behind Amhara opposition to the new structuring, they claim they were not represented when the federal system was adapted. That is not entirely correct because there were many Amhara intellectuals and political groups and individuals when the new constitution was created.

The real reason why only the Amhara elites and to some extent the general population bitterly oppose the Ethiopian federal structure and the new constitution is hidden behind a fake agenda called “Ethiopiawinet”.  The first real reason is the Ethiopian political power was monopolized by Amharas and they lost is when TPLF/EPRDF came to power. The second reason is the Amharas are the most dispersed ethnic group in Ethiopia. About half of the total population of Amharas lives outside of the regional state throughout the country.  Wherever they settled they expropriated the land of the local people by force.

Amharas think they have every right to own the land where they live even if their population is disproportional to the land they own.


These are the main real reasons why Amharas oppose the Ethiopian current federal arrangement. Amharas wanted to take more than their share like the old times, but it is imposible to do in the current arrangement. Amharas dodn’t love Ethiopia more than any Ethiopian or care about Ethiopian unity more than the next ethnic group. They claim they paid more than any other people to protect Ethiopia, but there has never been a single war that was fought only by Amharas and won in the history of Ethiopia.

Due to the geographic location and proximity to the red sea, all the invaders came through Eritrea and Tigrai. The battles of Gundet 1875, Gura 1876, Aylet 1887, and Senhit 1880 against the Egyptians, Sahati 1887, Dogali 1887 against the Italian invaders and many more battles were fought and won one hundred percent by Tigraians. In the above battles the Tigrai heroic troops annihilated the Egyptian and Italian invading armies with the superior leadership of Ras Alula Engida Equbi the famous African military general under Emperor Yohannes IV, King of Zion. In the above decisive battles there weren’t any Amharas or other Ethiopians. So, there is no factual ground for the fairytale that the Amharas tale the world they defended Ethiopia for centuries.


They were not even able to defend the old capital, Gonder when it was ravaged by the Mahdists, but it was the Tigrai army led by Emperor Yohannes IV that ejected the Sudanese invaders and the blessed Emperor gave his life to defend it.

The so called political analysts are barking in the wrong tree when they are blaming the Ethiopian federal structure and the Ethiopian constitution for all the chaos in Ethiopia including what is going on in southern Ethiopia this week.

We think all the questions of statehood in southern Ethiopia should be addressed in democratic, respectful, peaceful and transparent manner as soon as possible. The Ethiopian government is sending federal security forces including regular army troops to stop the unrest, but using force wouldn’t solve the root cause of the issue.

The federal government or any other force should not touch the Ethiopian constitution or the federal system for any reason. Doing so will have a dire consequences for Ethiopia and the entire Horn of Africa region.


The Sidama Question, Democratic Self-determination and Federalism

Is Prime Minister Abiy really a reformer or a deformer in Ethiopia

Rotten and Fractured Beyond Repair, EPRDF no More: Emergency Exit for TPLF, Now! Part III

The futile attempt of Amharas to create an Ethiopia on their image is destroying it

Federation of Nation States: The only viable option for Ethiopia

Putschism and the Deepening Crisis of Amhara Nationalists

Who could possibly be behind the assassinations of General Seare Mekonnen and Major General Gezae Abera?

Reforms by Abiy Ahmed Have Unleashed Forces He Can No Longer Control in Ethiopia

Impact of Pardons by Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and the Status of EPRDF

Amhara extremists in Ethiopia are disillusioned after failed government takeover

Who released the monster Asaminew Tsige out of his cage?

Ethiopian government said there was coup datat in Amhara Regional State

The destiny of Tigrai will be determined only by the people of Tigrai

The campaign against Tigrai is being formalized by all levels of Ethiopian governments

The campaign against Tigrai is being formalized by all levels of Ethiopian governments

Ethiopia Ranks low in the Global Peace Index (GPI) for 2019

Ethiopia could fragment on regional and religious lines like Yugoslavia, USA panel

Ahistorical Analysis and Psychological Profile of Emperor Yohannes IV by Professor Asmerom Legesse

Ethiopian government is preventing students from leavening their universities

Ethiopian leader is mediating in Sudan while Ethiopia is in a verge of collapse

Alarming ethnic based attacks and targeted killings of civilians in Ethiopia

May 28, 1991 and the Speech which the Prime Minister, Abiy Ahmed should have given

The Rise of Dark Forces in Ethiopia Alarming Situation

Identity Politics in Ethiopia: The Quest For Sovereignty

Eritrea celebrates its 28th independence day as calls for more freedom get louder

Ethiopian prime minister throws $173,000 a seat lavish dinner party in Addis Ababa

Ethnicity and Freedom of Movement in Ethiopia

Abiy Ahmed Ali preparing to invade Afar Regional State in Ethiopia

Ethiopia is a mosaic of Ethnicities

Getachew Assefa a revered hero of our generation

Ethiopian Garment Workers, Paid Lowest Wages in Apparel Industry

Ethiopia is led by pseudo leaders who are neither charismatic nor competent, hiding behind sweet but empty words